Search

Clownin'

Remembering Myself, Travestying Time

Aadujeevitham by Benyamin: Review

Unpopular Opinion Ahead!!

Reading Malayalam since a very long time, and it took me many attempts to finish. Honestly, 5 years! The story was something I already knew in parts. The language is not so great, I felt. Primarily because I didn’t like the protagonist Najeeb at all and it was his narration. I had no sympathy for him because he seemed to be too wishy washy and self righteous. His suffering is however deeply horrifying. Yet the narration is in understatement which seems to reduce the viscerality of his experiences. Am I moved? Yes, of course, in places. 

Cons: There are fluctuations in the narration; no single emotion is sustained for long, at least for not over a chapter. The novel jumps from nightmarish to self-deprecatingly humourous to caricature and back again. The long delay of actually breaking into the story, the too many rather detailed descriptions of Hakeem and life in prison, while the 3 year long Masara life could have benefited from more details. Instead Masara experiences are like anecdotes, sparsely worded, save for the desert escape. The bestiality and other “sexual-interest” anecdotes are like garnishing that feel like gimmicks of a seasoned writer rather than a survivor narrator.

Rating: 3.5/5

Comic strip adaptation of Jayanta Mahapatra’s “Dawn at Puri”

Quote #126

I was only twenty-four at the time. My life even then was gloomy, disorderly, and solitary to the point of savagery. I had no friends or acquaintances, avoided talking to people, and buried myself more and more in my hole. When at work in the office I tried not to look at anyone and I knew perfectly well that my colleagues not only regarded me as a queer fellow, but also I couldn’t help feeling that, too looked upon me with a sort of loathing. I wondered why no one except me had ever had this feeling that people looked upon him with loathing.[…] It is of course clear that, owing to my unbounded vanity and hence also to my over-sensitiveness where my own person was concerned, I often looked at myself with a sort of furious dissatisfaction which verged on loathing, and for that reason I could not help attributing my own views to other people. I hated my own face, for instance, finding it odious to a degree and even suspecting that it had rather a mean expression, and so every time I arrived at the office I went through agonies in my efforts to assume as independent an air as possible so as to make sure that my colleagues did not suspect me of meanness and so as to give my face as noble an expression as possible. “What do I care,” I thought to myself, “whether my face is ugly or not, so long as it is also noble, expressive, and, above all, extremely intelligent” But I knew very well, I knew it agonisingly well, that it was quite impossible for my face to express such high qualities. But the really dreadful part of it was that I thought my face looked absolutely stupid. I would have been completely satisfied if it looked intelligent. Indeed, I’d have reconciled myself even to a mean expression so long as my face was at the same time generally admitted to be awfully intelligent.

Fyodor Dostoesvsky. Notes from the Underground.

Quote #125

For man is stupid, phenomenally stupid, I mean, he may not be really stupid, but on the other hand he is so ungrateful that you won’t find anything like him in the whole wide world. I would not be at all surprised, for instance, if suddenly and without the slightest possible reason a gentleman of an ignoble or rather a reactionary and sardonic countenance were to arise amid all that future reign of universal common sense and, gripping his sides firmly with his hands, were to say to us all, “Well, gentlemen, what about giving all this common sense a mighty kick and letting it scatter in the dust before our feet simply to send all these logarithms to the devil so that we can again live according to our foolish will?” That wouldn’t matter, either, but for the regrettable fact that he would certainly find followers: for man is made like that. And all, mind you, for the most stupid of reasons which seems hardly worth mentioning, namely, because man has always and everywhere-whoever he may be preferred to do as he chose, and not in the least as his reason or advantage dictated; and one may choose to do something even if it is against one’s own advantage, and sometimes one positively should (that is my idea). One’s own free and unfettered choice, one’s own whims, however wild, one’s own fancy, overwrought though it sometimes may be to the point of madness-that is that same most desirable good which we over- looked and which does not fit into any classification, and against which all theories and systems are continually wrecked. And why on earth do all those sages assume that man must needs strive after some normal, after some rationally desirable good? All man wants is an absolutely free choice, however dear that freedom may cost him and wherever it may lead him to. Well, of course, if it is a matter of choice, then the devil only knows..

Fyodor Dostoevsky. Notes from the Underground.

Orbital by Samantha Harvey – Review

It is a fascinating read. The prose is fluid and beautiful. Space travel and the lives of astronauts in the space station are rendered in a sustained poetic and meditative diction. It’s a narrative style you fall in love with. Enough with the praise; let me get down to the hard truth, which is that the book was a light let-down because of its tapering brilliance.

I particularly liked the Japanese astronaut Chie (whose mother miraculously survived the atom bomb explosion), the descriptions of spacewalks, and the discussion of the Las Meninas painting. The ideas thin out towards the end of the narrative and the character development of its six astronauts, initially riveting, is unremarkable.  The narratival perspective – sometimes overlapping with the astronauts’- seems privileged and blind to the harsher realities down on the earth. The tone verges on the idealistic, speaking of scientific aspirations and an impersonal aesthetic contemplation of space and the planet. Environmental damage, political divisions, natural disaster, space junk, human corruption, the physical-emotional changes during life in space, the immanent presence of death, and the economic, showbiz aspects of space travel – everything is there, yet the scope of the narrative appears to leave much unsaid.

The ending seemed to me hurried and inadequate for a novel of such philosophical beauty. The aftermath of the tornado in the Philippines – an event that was predicted to be catastrophic – is described in detail, although by this time we aren’t too bothered with it, nor with the fate of the fisherman’s family (that shared an accidental point of contact with one of the astronauts while he was on earth). The fisherman and his family are alive and safe, declares the narrator, for no particular reason, since many others on the island have perished in the disaster. The assurance seems like a fairy tale conclusion to what is essentially a reflection about life and the smallness of paltry human life on a paltry but lovely planet.

Here are some quotations from the novel:

And in time we come to see that not only are we on the sidelines of the universe but that it's of a universe of sidelines, that there is no centre, just a giddy mass of waltzing things, and that perhaps the entirety of our understanding consists of an elaborate and ever-evolving knowledge of our own extraneousness, a bashing away of mankind's ego by the instruments of scientific enquiry until it is, that ego, a shattered edifice that lets light through.
Continue reading “Orbital by Samantha Harvey – Review” →

Shogun (2024): A Must-See Classic

Where to watch: Disney Hotstar

I would place Shogun among the ranks of Vikings and Peaky Blinders in my personal canon. It is a readaptation of the film based on the eponymous 1975 novel by James Clavell. I haven’t seen or read either, but this series deserves accolades for itself. It’s an immediate classic. Recounting the bittersweet encounter between an Englishman and the Japanese during the Edo period, Shogun shines with its heartbreaking poetry of visuals and thought, great cast and brilliant script.

The three best things about the series:

1. Steady and natural character development. Nothing appears incongruous or forced. The characters of Mariko, Blackthorne, Toranaga, Kiku, Yabushige, mould easily into real, complex persons naturally in the course of the series. I particularly loved Toranaga and Yabushige, both deep studies of personality and disparate types of the courageous.

2. Depiction of the East – West conflict. Preconceptions of both the Westerner (Blackthorne) and the Eastern (the Japanese) regarding the other are subverted. Simplistic and reductive stereotypes are discovered to be meaningless and inconsequential in the face of the higher philosophy of universal human behaviour. Even the language barrier breaks when like minds are able to reciprocate and empathise with each other.

3. Its philosophy of language and expression of emotions. Despite what I say in point two above, translation — of words, meanings, intentions, and cultural practices — indeed becomes a central issue for the narrative.  Language is often inadequate, and silence, a better medium of communication. Much is communicated through gaze, body language and strategic pauses. The poetry of sorrow, of life and death that runs across the narrative is heartbreaking.

(P.S.: I wanted to flesh out this review with a lot of examples from the series, but then, I think I might not be able to do justice to the series; it deserves close study rather than a superficial opinion piece. Also, this is one of my rare positive reviews, and I’m a chronic pessimist, a paradoxical situation. I cannot elaborate for fear of doing further damage to this identity. So ciao.)

Review: The Good Girls (2021): An Ordinary Killing by Sonia Faleiro

Contains spoilers. Journalistic fiction about the 2014 Budaun case of the deaths of two minor low caste girls in Uttar Pradesh, India.

The prologue and character list at the beginning of the novel is  like the staging of a play, a dramatic flourish to the narrative. The vast ensemble of characters and digressive flashbacks in the story of a killing that is ‘ordinary’ implicates not merely the murderers, but an entire village, a mentality, a culture, a nation and its histories. Written for a foreign western audience, published by Penguin, the book spends a lot of time for exposition and adopts a tone of NRI disbelief and cultural distance. The narrator POV is that of an ashamed Indian  exposing India to the Western reader who knows little about the ground realities of the facade of “developing” India, like the tone of Adiga in The White Tiger. Politically, the narrative voice is that of a leftist feminist, liberal, critical of New India’s hypocritical nationalism, middle class complacency, and structural discrimination towards gender, caste and minorities. Modi, Mayawati, Akhilesh Yadav, Lalu Prasad, Yogi — names are dropped, political parties incriminated.

Continue reading “Review: The Good Girls (2021): An Ordinary Killing by Sonia Faleiro” →

On C-section

In the next months there would be many more such bodily humiliations. In the presence of serious injuries, your body’s privacy ceases to exist, you lose autonomy over your physical self, over the vessel in which you sail. You allow this because you have no alternative. You surrender the captaincy of your ship so that it won’t sink. You allow people to do what they will with your body—to prod and drain and inject and stitch and inspect your nakedness—so that you can live.

Salman Rushdie. Knife. 2024.

I can’t help but relate to this. Isn’t every labour-csection process exactly like this? To suspend one’s bodily autonomy and every shred of dignity and to lie at the mercy of “medical strangers”. I recently went through such a process and haven’t got over its trauma yet. I try to forget the whole nightmare but have panic attacks whenever I am reminded of it. Is it just me or is it common? If it is common, why is no one talking about it? I felt humiliated to my utmost core, degraded, and dehumanised surrounded by medical personnel with their “years of expertise”. If it was not for them, I (or one of “us”, in my case) would have died, that’s true. But I had never imagined such helplessness and degradation.

Thoughts on Ripley (2024): Pretense, Pretentious

I loved The Talented Mr Ripley so much and without having read the book yet that I expected much from the Netflix series Ripley.

First of all among the problems I had about the series, there was Andrew Scott, who is just marvellous as usual. He is a Ripley difficult to hate or despise, unlike Matt Damon’s act. And herein lies the problem. Damon’s obsession with and usurpation of the identity of the rich, educated, and unemployed Dickie had moments where you squirm and cower with embarrassment and anxiety. Damon was a pretender, and a pretender who often subtly gave away the pretense. Scott, however, only pretends to be pretender, he is always Ripley, meticulous and genuine, who takes on the guise of Dickie as an “adventure”, a kind of experiment in discovering the real Tom Ripley. He seems always so sure of what he is doing and saying. He is a person who you want both to win and lose.

Secondly, there is the matter of Caravaggio who pervades the narrative like a thorn in your foot. The numerous allusions to the painter, his work and life, particularly his murder of a pimp and his own grisly murder, are no doubt informative despite being forced. Ripley is associated with Caravaggio, their lives crossing each other in their alikeness, their works (art and murder) eerily made similar.

And thirdly, there’s the absence of colour. The series is in monochrome. The picturesque scenery of Italy and the paintings, especially after Poor Things have bombarded our senses with its outlandish burst of colour, are plainly and most disorientingly black and white. I’m not fond of colours myself, and indeed, the frames are beautifully-shot  studies in light and shadow, but the choice of palette still seems a tad pretentious.

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free