
Unpopular Opinion Ahead!!
Reading Malayalam since a very long time, and it took me many attempts to finish. Honestly, 5 years! The story was something I already knew in parts. The language is not so great, I felt. Primarily because I didn’t like the protagonist Najeeb at all and it was his narration. I had no sympathy for him because he seemed to be too wishy washy and self righteous. His suffering is however deeply horrifying. Yet the narration is in understatement which seems to reduce the viscerality of his experiences. Am I moved? Yes, of course, in places.
Cons: There are fluctuations in the narration; no single emotion is sustained for long, at least for not over a chapter. The novel jumps from nightmarish to self-deprecatingly humourous to caricature and back again. The long delay of actually breaking into the story, the too many rather detailed descriptions of Hakeem and life in prison, while the 3 year long Masara life could have benefited from more details. Instead Masara experiences are like anecdotes, sparsely worded, save for the desert escape. The bestiality and other “sexual-interest” anecdotes are like garnishing that feel like gimmicks of a seasoned writer rather than a survivor narrator.
Rating: 3.5/5




